top of page

Why Your Child Says "I Don't Know" When You Ask How They Feel

Nov 6
7 min read

You notice that something is bothering your child. Perhaps they have been unusually quiet after school, become upset over something seemingly small, or withdrawn from activities they usually enjoy. You sit beside them, hoping to understand what is going on, and gently ask, "How are you feeling?"



Their response is simple. "I don't know." You try again, perhaps asking whether something happened at school or whether someone upset them. But the answer remains the same. "I don't know." For many parents, this can be frustrating and confusing. It may feel as though their child is deliberately withholding information, avoiding the conversation, or refusing to open up. Yet what adults sometimes interpret as reluctance to communicate may actually reflect something much more complex.


Sometimes, when children say they don't know how they feel, they genuinely don't know.


Children experience emotions long before they develop the language and self-awareness needed to understand or explain them. While adults may be able to recognise feelings of disappointment, embarrassment, jealousy, anxiety, or frustration, young children are still learning to identify the differences between these emotional experiences. For a child, feelings can arrive as an overwhelming mixture of physical sensations, thoughts, and emotions that are difficult to separate. They may know that something feels uncomfortable, but not understand why. They may feel angry without recognising that sadness or disappointment lies underneath. They may experience anxiety as a stomach ache, restlessness, or an unexplained desire to avoid a particular situation. When asked to explain these experiences, "I don't know" may be the most accurate answer they can give.


Understanding the Gap Between Feeling and Expressing


Emotional awareness is a developmental skill, not something children are automatically born knowing how to do. Learning to recognise, name, and communicate emotions takes time. It develops through relationships, experiences, observation, and repeated opportunities to explore feelings in a safe environment. Young children often begin with broad emotional categories such as happy, sad, angry, or scared. As they grow, their emotional understanding becomes more sophisticated. They gradually learn that sadness can feel different from disappointment, that nervousness may exist alongside excitement, and that anger can sometimes be connected to embarrassment, hurt, or fear. Even older children may struggle to put complicated feelings into words, particularly when they are overwhelmed.


Imagine a child who has spent the day feeling excluded by a group of friends. They may have experienced rejection, embarrassment, sadness, and anger, all within the same interaction. By the time they return home, they may simply feel irritable or exhausted. When a parent asks what happened, the child may struggle to identify which part of the experience upset them most. They might not even recognise that the friendship difficulty is connected to how they are feeling. Their emotional experience is real, but their understanding of it is still developing.

This is why asking children to explain their feelings is not always as straightforward as it sounds.


When Talking About Feelings Feels Overwhelming


Sometimes children know that something is bothering them, but talking about it feels too difficult. Emotional experiences can be uncomfortable, especially when children are still learning how to manage them. Being asked to describe something painful or confusing may bring those feelings closer to the surface before the child feels ready to explore them.


A child who has experienced conflict with a friend may worry about becoming upset again. A child who feels ashamed about something that happened at school may fear disappointing their parents. Another child may struggle to explain their feelings because they are worried about how adults will respond.


In these situations, "I don't know" can become a protective response. It creates distance from a conversation that may feel emotionally demanding. This does not necessarily mean the child is being dishonest or intentionally avoiding their parents. Sometimes, they simply need more time, reassurance, or emotional safety before they feel comfortable exploring what happened.


For children who are highly sensitive, anxious, or neurodivergent, identifying and communicating internal experiences may be particularly challenging. Some children experience difficulties with recognising and describing emotions, sometimes referred to as alexithymia. Others may find direct questions overwhelming, especially after a long day of managing social, academic, and sensory demands. Not every child who says "I don't know" is experiencing emotional distress, however. Sometimes the question is simply too broad, the child is distracted, or they would prefer to talk later. Understanding the context matters.


Why Children Often Communicate More Through Behaviour Than Words


One of the most important things parents can understand is that children do not communicate exclusively through language. Their behaviour, play, body language, and relationships can all provide clues about how they are experiencing the world. A child who cannot explain why they feel anxious may become unusually clingy before school. A child struggling with frustration may begin throwing toys or becoming upset when things do not go their way. A child experiencing uncertainty at home may become more controlling during play or find changes in routine difficult. These behaviours do not provide a diagnosis or tell us exactly what a child is feeling. However, they can invite us to become curious about what may be happening beneath the surface.


It can be tempting to focus entirely on helping children explain themselves verbally. Yet when a child is emotionally overwhelmed, asking repeated questions can sometimes increase their frustration. They may begin to feel pressured to provide an answer they do not have.


Instead of creating connection, the conversation can unintentionally become another expectation they feel unable to meet. Sometimes, children communicate more openly when the pressure to talk is removed. A child may share something important while drawing, building with blocks, playing with toys, or sitting beside a parent during an ordinary activity. These quieter moments can feel less demanding because the child is not required to maintain eye contact, organise complicated thoughts, or respond immediately. Connection does not always begin with a conversation. Sometimes, it begins with simply being together.


How Play Therapy Helps Children Express What They Cannot Say


Within play therapy, the understanding that children communicate differently from adults is central to the therapeutic process. While adults often process experiences through conversation, children frequently explore their internal world through play. A child may not be able to explain that they feel powerless in a particular situation, but themes involving control, strength, or vulnerability may emerge during play. Another child may struggle to describe fears surrounding separation, yet repeatedly create stories about characters leaving, returning, or searching for safety. These experiences can offer opportunities for exploration within a supportive therapeutic relationship.


Importantly, play therapists do not assume that a particular toy, story, or play theme has one fixed meaning. Children's play is complex, and understanding it requires attention to the individual child, their developmental stage, relationships, experiences, and wider circumstances. Play therapy provides a space where children are not required to explain themselves before they are ready. Through developmentally appropriate therapeutic play, children can explore difficult feelings, develop emotional awareness, and practise new ways of expressing and managing their experiences.


For some children, this gradually makes it easier to recognise and communicate emotions outside the playroom as well. The goal is not necessarily to turn every child into someone who can articulate their feelings perfectly. Rather, it is to help them develop a greater sense of emotional understanding, safety, and confidence in expressing themselves.


What Parents Can Do When Their Child Says "I Don't Know"


When children struggle to explain their feelings, one of the most helpful things parents can offer is patience. Instead of asking the same question repeatedly, parents can acknowledge what they notice without demanding an explanation. A simple observation such as, "You seem a little quieter than usual today," can communicate care without placing pressure on the child to respond. Parents might also reassure their child that it is okay not to know what they are feeling. Saying, "That's okay. Sometimes feelings are hard to figure out. We can talk about it whenever you're ready," helps create an environment where emotional expression feels safe rather than compulsory.


For younger children, offering simple choices may make emotions easier to identify. Instead of asking an open-ended question such as "How are you feeling?", a parent might gently ask, "Does it feel more like you're sad, frustrated, or worried?" It is equally important to leave room for the child to disagree or say that none of those feelings seem right. Books, stories, drawing, imaginative play, and everyday conversations about emotions can also help children build emotional vocabulary naturally.


Parents can model this by talking about their own feelings in age-appropriate ways. When adults say things such as, "I felt frustrated when my plans changed, so I took a moment to calm down," children begin to learn that emotions can be recognised, expressed, and managed without shame. Most importantly, parents can remember that emotional communication develops through connection, not interrogation. Children are more likely to explore difficult feelings when they trust that their emotions will be received with curiosity rather than criticism.


If a child's difficulty expressing emotions is accompanied by persistent withdrawal, anxiety, significant behavioural changes, or difficulties with everyday functioning, it may be helpful to seek guidance from a qualified professional.


Looking Beyond "I Don't Know"

As adults, we sometimes forget how complicated emotions can feel when we are still learning to understand them.


Even grown-ups struggle to explain why they feel overwhelmed, disconnected, anxious, or upset. We may spend hours reflecting on an experience before recognising what was actually bothering us.


For children, this process can be even more difficult. When a child says "I don't know," it does not necessarily mean they are unwilling to communicate. They may be struggling to recognise their emotions, organise their thoughts, find the right words, or feel safe enough to explore something difficult.


Sometimes, they may simply need permission not to have an answer. At Flow & Flourish, we believe that understanding children begins with recognising that their emotional worlds are often richer and more complex than their words can express.

Through play, connection, and emotionally safe relationships, children can gradually develop the confidence to understand themselves and communicate their experiences.

The next time your child responds with "I don't know," consider what might happen if the conversation did not need an immediate answer.


Perhaps what your child needs most in that moment is not another question, but the reassurance that you are there, that their feelings matter, and that they do not have to understand everything they are experiencing to deserve support.


Because sometimes, the most meaningful emotional conversations begin when we stop expecting children to find the right words.


Do you think your Teen or Child could benefit from therapy? Speak to a qualified Play therapist to learn how your Teen or Child could benefit from play therapy. Click here to get in touch today, or if you want to know if Play Therapy could be suitable for your Teen or Child, click here to take our quiz!

 
 
 

Comments


flow and flourish Play Therapy

The Flow & Flourish Practice

​

We believe every child deserves to feel seen, heard, and understood. Through evidence-based play therapy, we support children, adolescents, and families in navigating life's challenges with confidence, resilience, and hope.

 

Our compassionate, child-centred approach creates a safe space where children can express themselves, heal, and flourish.

+65 9100 0752

📍  Orchard 

📍  Mountbatten

AUT PLAY
PSA
PTUK

CONNECT WITH US

Follow us on Instagram • Facebook • LinkedIn

We are an independent play therapy provider. For official play therapy training and accreditation (PTUK), please visit playtherapy.sg

Contact Us

© 2026 The Flow & Flourish Practice. All Rights Reserved.

bottom of page